Worst Sen Ever

I was debating with someone on facebook (briefly, until I got annoyed) who was saying that Campoli was the worst Sen ever. I thought that that was dumb. He was a serviceable, late pairing D-man who was fairly steady, cheap, and could log 2nd PP unit time. I have nothing bad to say about the guy.

Either way, it got me to thinking. Who's the worst Senator? I had a serious hate on for Schastlivy, but a case could easily be made for Kovalev. I didn't like Bonk either. Meh...the point is, who do you think is the worst Sen ever?

Pascal Leclaire

Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

DirtyDave wrote:Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

hmm...I liked Smolinski.

Considering what Bondra cost us, that's a pretty good selection.

Arneson

NEELY wrote:Arneson

Arnason was a bad pickup too. I don't understand how he was successful in Colorado. He was a bad player, IMO.

Is his name Robert Persson, that D-man who took a 5 minute penalty and cost us the game (and series) against TO? That guy sucked badly.

Shartslivy or whatever that Russian guy's name was, I think we traded him to the Ducks.

Arneson blew as well, but he wasn't given much of a chance because Murray disliked him from the get-go I think.

Arnason is my vote. I'd also submit the name of Mr. No Goals Bill Muckalt.

DirtyDave wrote:Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

Smolinski? Are you kidding? Personally, I was a big fan of Smolinski.

Madness.

Worst Sen? I'd say Kovalev, but that's cuz I hate him.



Commodore, Arnason, Hnidy, Neckar... Zubov...

DirtyDave wrote:Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

I can't hate anyone who knocks Connelly out cold...

SpezDispenser wrote:Is his name Robert Persson, that D-man who took a 5 minute penalty and cost us the game (and series) against TO? That guy sucked badly.

Shartslivy or whatever that Russian guy's name was, I think we traded him to the Ducks.

Arneson blew as well, but he wasn't given much of a chance because Murray disliked him from the get-go I think.

Well, theres also Christer Olsson who played a grand total of 25 games for us. He was of course traded for Pavol Demitra, who went on to become a very good NHLer.

shabbs wrote:

DirtyDave wrote:Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

Smolinski? Are you kidding? Personally, I was a big fan of Smolinski.

Madness.

Worst Sen? I'd say Kovalev, but that's cuz I hate him.



Commodore, Arnason, Hnidy, Neckar... Zubov...

He doesn't count. Nor does Kaigorodov, Chouinard, etc. People who came to the team and played significant minutes only please.

NEELY wrote:Arneson

Apparently the story behind that trade was Muckler thought he was trading for Calder. He was such a bad GM

DirtyDave wrote:

NEELY wrote:Arneson

Apparently the story behind that trade was Muckler thought he was trading for Calder. He was such a bad GM

spader wrote:

shabbs wrote:

DirtyDave wrote:Bondra or Smolinski or Schafer

Smolinski? Are you kidding? Personally, I was a big fan of Smolinski.

Madness.

Worst Sen? I'd say Kovalev, but that's cuz I hate him.



Commodore, Arnason, Hnidy, Neckar... Zubov...

He doesn't count. Nor does Kaigorodov, Chouinard, etc. People who came to the team and played significant minutes only please.

Don't recall reading those requirements in the original post...