I voted Redden. I'd say most of those guys at least had a good season prior to signing those deals. Redden played awful and still got rewarded for it.
Jason Blake - 40 goals
Brian Campbell - high demand for OFD, excellent mobile puck mover
Cristoball Huet - #1 in MTL played pretty well "Huet Dit Non"
Shawn Horcoff - NHL all-star
Rostislav Olesz - young with potential
Scott Gomez - stanley cup championships, played on NJD dynasty
Brian Rolston - stanley cup championships
Chris Drury - cup ring, played on a stacked Sabres team
Rick DiPietro - young, played well before injuries ruined his career
Jeff Finger - not a horrible shutdown player
Jason Blake - 40 goals
Brian Campbell - high demand for OFD, excellent mobile puck mover
Cristoball Huet - #1 in MTL played pretty well "Huet Dit Non"
Shawn Horcoff - NHL all-star
Rostislav Olesz - young with potential
Scott Gomez - stanley cup championships, played on NJD dynasty
Brian Rolston - stanley cup championships
Chris Drury - cup ring, played on a stacked Sabres team
Rick DiPietro - young, played well before injuries ruined his career
Jeff Finger - not a horrible shutdown player