N4L wrote:The two things that I couldnt stand from last night were A Train and Clouston. A Train was awful, no excuses for how bad that guy was. He cant keep playing like that otherwise he will get shipped out, especially to make room for someone like Lee and eventually Cowen.
As for Clouston, if there was one matchup in that game where we were domianted, it was coach vs coach. He had no clue what to do, how to get things going, and anything that was successful in pre season he just ignored. Why was Foligno not with Regin and Fisher. Why would you have Karlsson and Campoli out together? Even to generate offense that is not a good idea, at all, especially in the first game of the season where Karlsson was showing he was a rookie.
As for someone who said I trash Lee and said he was an NHL bust. Ya, never said he was an NHL bust, said he was a 1st round bust, get it right. I also said there is a lot of potential there on numerous occasions and said he needs a big shut down partner with him (like Phillips or Cowen) to make him a better D man and possible after a decent amount of time, part of a 3/4 pairing. We have had lengthy discussions about it that I invite you to join to you dont run your mouth and say things that are not true.
I re-read what I wrote about A Train there, came out wrong. I didnt mean we should deal him to make room for Lee or anyone else, just that he would be the guy getting dealt, especially if they are going with Cowen and Lee next year. Get something for the asset.
On top of that, A Train didnt have a strong finish to last year on top of getting off to about the worst start you could this year. If he doesnt improve he will be dealt, garenteed. You would rather give Lee a shot and gain some expierence and put up with his young mistakes then A Train's. That was a BAD BAD game by A Train.
Cheechoo looked good though, impressed with him. Alfi looked like Alfi. Carkner was fairly impressive in that 6th role, worked Brashere too. Regin looked good, he's just going to get better. LOVED Neil, looks like his old self again. Spezza has to be better, plain and simple, that was not a good start for him either. I like his effort for the most part bt he got nothing done offensivly.
I hate Michalek on that top line, they are not clicking at all. Put a guy who doesnt have the puck much, has a good shot, and can score goals, like say ummmm, Cheechoo! This has been the most obvious combo since the trade. A 2nd/3rd line of Kovalev/Shannon/Michalek isnt a bad idea.
Only the first game of the year but the two beefs we fairly big problems IMO.
I certainly don't disagree that A-Train could be dealt, but I think his contract status may have more to do with it than his actual play. That and the fact that we are clearly going with a youth movement back there going forward. Plus, I think he's got some real value, particularly at the deadline when a guy like him will be at a premium, but I don't think he's being moved to make room for anyone this season barring a trade. I won't touch the Lee thing again, since you obviously backpedalled on that. The only thing I can ever remember you saying even remotely postive about him was that he formed a nice pairing with Cowen - a guy who isn't here. I have no beef with you are doing it now, but don't pretend you haven't had a massive hate on for the guy historically. Funny, how selective your memory is.
I don't think Lee is ready for a full time role considering the other bodies we've got atm, including A-Train.
As far as Volchenkov goes, I'm not ready to start saying he needs to pick it up etc. It's one game, and yes, he wasn't stellar last season, but neither was most of the team. He's done enough for this team to at least earn a grace period from criticism,at least from me.
I'll agree that Michalek and Spezza shouldn't be together. I'd like to see Michalek with Shannon and Fisher, two guys who've got nice speed to compliment Milan. Spezza and Kovalev would be another tandem I'd like to see together to see if they can generate some chemistry.