GM Hockey
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
GM Hockey

You are not connected. Please login or register

Ottawa Senators (present and past) TIDBITS & QUICK HITS!

+11
Oglethorpe
LeCaptain
NEELY
Ev
DefenceWinsChampionships
Cap'n Clutch
SeawaySensFan
Flo The Action
PTFlea
wprager
tim1_2
15 posters

Go to page : Previous  1 ... 25 ... 47, 48, 49 ... 57 ... 67  Next

Go down  Message [Page 48 of 67]

tim1_2


Franchise Player
Franchise Player

Yeah, it's tough to expect guys to be traded easily when these are the same guys we're Dung on constantly.

I think Matrix can garner a decent return, but we might have to wait for a couple key injuries closer to the deadline.

NEELY


Mod
Mod

SpezDispensed wrote:He's seen it all, let's not pretend that he's sitting there rocking back and forth insisting this is a playoff team.  Perhaps this should have been a playoff team - if we had gotten a vet scorer and a healthy Methot, but that's that.

What he'll do now is what any GM would do, he'll start quietly letting teams know that the veterans are for sale at any time and to begin offering away, but what do you want him to do at this point?  

Legwand is on the block.  I would pretty much guarantee it.  Michalek might or might not, who knows how he's regarded in the room.  Perhaps they want to keep him as a third liner, who knows.  Methot needs to be re-signed soon.  Phillips should be quietly on the block with the pretense that he's being moved to a contender to take a shot at the Cup (while he just needs to be Old Yellered), Wiercioch is certainly on the block, but who would care?  Smith sucks now and is redundant to 90% of teams out there, so good luck with that.  Neil probably isn't on the block, so you can probably forget about that.

Maybe Anderson is being quietly offered around, maybe.  I doubt it because Lehner's shown nothing really, but perhaps they want to begin the Lehner era here in Ottawa.  Which is funny, because all we've wanted in Ottawa is a solid netminder and now we have one and we can't wait to trade him.

The bottom line is, I think Murray knows what he's doing and I think he's got the feelers out to get rid of the dead weight, but who would care around the league?

Minny is pretty much out of it at this point, with or without Anderson.  They're in a dogfight in the West and their D is porous, and that's one of the few teams I can see really wanting Anderson.   Edmonton?  Probably a chance to get Eberle, but what's the cost?  And on and on we go.  Remember that this league is near impossible to make trades in, especially when you're offering prime pieces like Chris 'take me out back and shoot me' Phillips.

Everything but a Cup

SeawaySensFan


Franchise Player
Franchise Player

tim1_2 wrote:Yeah, it's tough to expect guys to be traded easily when these are the same guys we're Dung on constantly.

I think Matrix can garner a decent return, but we might have to wait for a couple key injuries closer to the deadline.

Who says those are the guys being offered around? Just wishful thinking from the fans. It could just as well be favourites like Turdiss and Leonard being dealt.

NEELY


Mod
Mod

If they want Anderson to be the #1 then trade Lehner. Cups are won with a clear cut #1 guy and leaving Lehner flapping in the wind at this point, stalling any kind of development, and generally forcing him into a backup role he isn't supposed to be in is failing the player. Murray has no idea how to handle this situation IMO and I don't think you can trust him to make the right moves at this point. He's seeing something that isn't there which is concerning.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

NEELY wrote:
SpezDispensed wrote:He's seen it all, let's not pretend that he's sitting there rocking back and forth insisting this is a playoff team.  Perhaps this should have been a playoff team - if we had gotten a vet scorer and a healthy Methot, but that's that.

What he'll do now is what any GM would do, he'll start quietly letting teams know that the veterans are for sale at any time and to begin offering away, but what do you want him to do at this point?  

Legwand is on the block.  I would pretty much guarantee it.  Michalek might or might not, who knows how he's regarded in the room.  Perhaps they want to keep him as a third liner, who knows.  Methot needs to be re-signed soon.  Phillips should be quietly on the block with the pretense that he's being moved to a contender to take a shot at the Cup (while he just needs to be Old Yellered), Wiercioch is certainly on the block, but who would care?  Smith sucks now and is redundant to 90% of teams out there, so good luck with that.  Neil probably isn't on the block, so you can probably forget about that.

Maybe Anderson is being quietly offered around, maybe.  I doubt it because Lehner's shown nothing really, but perhaps they want to begin the Lehner era here in Ottawa.  Which is funny, because all we've wanted in Ottawa is a solid netminder and now we have one and we can't wait to trade him.

The bottom line is, I think Murray knows what he's doing and I think he's got the feelers out to get rid of the dead weight, but who would care around the league?

Minny is pretty much out of it at this point, with or without Anderson.  They're in a dogfight in the West and their D is porous, and that's one of the few teams I can see really wanting Anderson.   Edmonton?  Probably a chance to get Eberle, but what's the cost?  And on and on we go.  Remember that this league is near impossible to make trades in, especially when you're offering prime pieces like Chris 'take me out back and shoot me' Phillips.

Everything but a Cup

One of the most elusive things in sports to win though, but yeah, at some point a finisher will have to come in for him unfortunately.

tim1_2

tim1_2
Franchise Player
Franchise Player

NEELY wrote:If they want Anderson to be the #1 then trade Lehner. Cups are won with a clear cut #1 guy and leaving Lehner flapping in the wind at this point, stalling any kind of development, and generally forcing him into a backup role he isn't supposed to be in is failing the player. Murray has no idea how to handle this situation IMO and I don't think you can trust him to make the right moves at this point. He's seeing something that isn't there which is concerning.

I think the plan was to continually give Lehner more of a share of the net throughout Anderson's contract...and Lehner's inconsistency has lead to him not getting as many starts as they had likely originally intended. You can't just flip a switch on trading a goalie like Anderson, especially when you've been in playoff contention. As I said before, this is a move more likely to be made at the deadline or in the off-season.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

tim1_2 wrote:
NEELY wrote:If they want Anderson to be the #1 then trade Lehner.  Cups are won with a clear cut #1 guy and leaving Lehner flapping in the wind at this point, stalling any kind of development, and generally forcing him into a backup role he isn't supposed to be in is failing the player.  Murray has no idea how to handle this situation IMO and I don't think you can trust him to make the right moves at this point.  He's seeing something that isn't there which is concerning.

I think the plan was to continually give Lehner more of a share of the net throughout Anderson's contract...and Lehner's inconsistency has lead to him not getting as many starts as they had likely originally intended.  You can't just flip a switch on trading a goalie like Anderson, especially when you've been in playoff contention.  As I said before, this is a move more likely to be made at the deadline or in the off-season.  

Unless...we can Avalance/Landeskog someone like Edmonton, but I think it would take a lot more than Anderson to 'save' that team from drafting tops again.

NEELY


Mod
Mod

I'm fine if they decide to go with Anderson, he's a solid #1 and is best served playing 65 plus games... in the same breath I don't care what goalie is playing behind Anderson they will be inconsistent.  Lehner needs games, he's not getting better on the bench and playing every 3 weeks.  He's literally played 2 games in the last 5, 6 weeks and people expect him to come in and push Anderson out of the spot.  No one in the NHL is going to push Anderson out of that spot right now, he's been lights out.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

Did I hear on 1200 that Michalek is last in the league in even strength points? Last in the league? Can that be right?

tim1_2

tim1_2
Franchise Player
Franchise Player

SpezDispensed wrote:Did I hear on 1200 that Michalek is last in the league in even strength points? Last in the league? Can that be right?

Nah...must be among guys that have played a certain number of minutes or something....

NEELY


Mod
Mod

And hell, if there's a year you can afford Lehner to let in some softies and learn it's this year. Quick was a call-up in a bad year but he needed reps and got them. Remember the Price vs Halak debate like Ev brought up? Chicago let Neimi go... Pitt has stuck with Flurry through thick and thin... Boston made Tim Thomas move on with a somewhat unproven Rask... it goes on and on.

2 cooks in the kitchen doesn't work. Make a choice. There's a short term choice with very little risk in Anderson and there's a long term choice with some risk to it in Lehner. What these guys would get back in a trade aside they need to make a call.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

tim1_2 wrote:
SpezDispensed wrote:Did I hear on 1200 that Michalek is last in the league in even strength points?  Last in the league?  Can that be right?

Nah...must be among guys that have played a certain number of minutes or something....

Per 60 minutes they said.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

NEELY wrote:And hell, if there's a year you can afford Lehner to let in some softies and learn it's this year.  Quick was a call-up in a bad year but he needed reps and got them.  Remember the Price vs Halak debate like Ev brought up?  Chicago let Neimi go... Pitt has stuck with Flurry through thick and thin... Boston made Tim Thomas move on with a somewhat unproven Rask... it goes on and on.

2 cooks in the kitchen doesn't work.  Make a choice.  There's a short term choice with very little risk in Anderson and there's a long term choice with some risk to it in Lehner.  What these guys would get back in a trade aside they need to make a call.

Without looking, I'd say Rask had unreal numbers when they let Thomas walk. Niemi was never anything special really IMO. Price and Halak is an interesting one though. I would imagine Price had better numbers than Lehner as well. Lehner shows flashes, but he isn't there yet, so I'm not sure what they'll do.

Play him more is a start, because who really cares now?

NEELY


Mod
Mod

Lehner has had unreal numbers too but he wasn't given the ball. Lehner's development has completely stalled, he was ready for the #1 last year and it was yanked from him for absolutely no reason. I go back to that week where he was 1st start and MacLean f***ed him. People have short memories, Lehner was the best goaltender in the NHL for a very short period of time and deserved a lot more than he received. My concern at this point is how much damage has been done if there indeed has been damage done.

You're right, let him play or let him play somewhere else. Edmonton and Minny would kill for Lehner right now as I am sure a few other teams would. Again, make a choice because it's going to start to get stupid again in Ottawa with goaltenders.

NEELY


Mod
Mod

I don't know of any players in any position that develop on the bench night after night. Hell, even healthy scratches get more time than Lehner.

NEELY


Mod
Mod

Since Dec 20 Lehner has had 2 starts... good luck getting anything out of that.

SeawaySensFan

SeawaySensFan
Franchise Player
Franchise Player

NEELY wrote:Lehner has had unreal numbers too but he wasn't given the ball.   Lehner's development has completely stalled, he was ready for the #1 last year and it was yanked from him for absolutely no reason.  I go back to that week where he was 1st start and MacLean f***ed him.  People have short memories, Lehner was the best goaltender in the NHL for a very short period of time and deserved a lot more than he received.  My concern at this point is how much damage has been done if there indeed has been damage done.

You're right, let him play or let him play somewhere else.  Edmonton and Minny would kill for Lehner right now as I am sure a few other teams would.   Again, make a choice because it's going to start to get stupid again in Ottawa with goaltenders.

We'd be lucky to get anything for Lehner right now. The only people who think he's that good are a few Lehner groupies here on this website. Hopefully he bounces back but he has to be worth very little right now.

So yeah, make a choice between trading your best goalie or getting nothing for the other one. Anyone who preaches patience should be equally patient with the goalie situation.

PTFlea

PTFlea
Co-Founder
Co-Founder

It's been pretty messed up in Ottawa with the goalies. We all thought it would be 50/50, but Anderson's been one of the best goalies on the planet. Weird Dung, don't know what else to say.

I guess people are right, sell high on Anderson and believe in Lehner.

Sponsored content



Back to top  Message [Page 48 of 67]

Go to page : Previous  1 ... 25 ... 47, 48, 49 ... 57 ... 67  Next

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum