The same has been said of JFJ - great at scouting, not so great as GM or at contract negotiations... he should stick to scouting.
GM Hockey
Mojo wrote:Possibly the best topic title ever! It even works on the level of an attention-loving McGuire and stupid 18 year-old attention-loving girls lifting their shirts.
davetherave wrote:If things don't work in Minny, Pierre might consider a career in Hollywood...as a stunt double for Dana Carvey in the upcoming blockbuster comedy "Turtle Guy On Ice". Coming soon to a cineplex near you.
Dawg's Wife wrote:cash wrote:I just don't see how the guy could garner the respect from agents and fellow GMs that would be required to sign and trade efficiently...
I mean, you look at the faces of the guys on TSN when McGuire's talking and its pretty obvious that they don't even respect him.
Imagine what killer sharks like agents and good GMs would do to the guy....
This has bad move written all over it.
Funny you should mention this because I talked to Dawg about it last night. Regardless of how you view him, believe it or not McGuire is regarded very highly around NHL circles. He does know just about every up and coming player (thanks to TSN's coverage of the WJHC) and also is very up to speed with just about every pro player out there at an AHL or higher level.
The one negative he has in his lack of ability or experience if you wish to negotiate NHL contracts. That's really a non issue in today's NHL as most teams have a group of people (call them capologists) who are responsible for working the numbers to fit.
I will say this, getting him hired by the Wild or Avalanche would mean he's off Ottawa radio, and while I used to love the Wednesday's listener question segment, I've found lately (the last year or so) that he fawns over his favorites and shouts down those who disagree with his point of view.
Personally I think he'd be a great Chief of Scouting staff..but that isn't something he wants.
Off now, heading downtown Chicago and then a little nap before the big game tonight.
davetherave wrote:
Fletcher, the son of longtime NHL executive Cliff Fletcher, has been around the sport since he was a child. He has 16 years of experience with Florida, Anaheim and Pittsburgh, and he's only 41, working alongside some of the NHL's most respected executives -- Bill Torrey, Bobby Clarke, Bryan Murray, Brian Burke and now Ray Shero.
shabbs wrote:I hope he gets the job as I'm curious to see how it all unfolds...
May 20, 2009/CBSSports.com wire reports |
Pierre McGuire has become a prominent voice in hockey through years of blunt analysis from the broadcast booth. Now he's interested in running a team himself. The Minnesota Wild are evaluating their general manager opening, and McGuire is one of the finalists. He has played professionally in Europe, coached at the college level, and served in the NHL as a scout, assistant coach, assistant general manager and head coach. But McGuire's candidacy essentially comes from the nontraditional category. He hasn't been part of a team for 12 years, instead breaking down the game for Canada sports network TSN and more recently for U.S. viewers on NBC. That independent perspective, however, is the essence of his aspiration. "When you've done media as long as I have, you have a chance to be exposed to a lot of different markets and ideologies as far as how to build a program," McGuire said Wednesday in a phone interview with the Associated Press. "You've also seen the failures and what's gone wrong. It's a chance to evaluate with an unbiased eye what the positives and what the detriments are to building a team. That's what lured me." Wild owner Craig Leipold fired his president and general manager Doug Risebrough last month. Other names circulating around the league as possibilities for the job are Pittsburgh assistant general manager Chuck Fletcher and Anaheim assistant general manager David McNab. Acting general manager Tom Lynn, who was Risebrough's top assistant, is also in the mix. Bill Robertson, the Wild's vice president of communications and broadcasting, said the team won't comment on the search or speak specifically about any candidates. McGuire couldn't directly address the process, either. While driving to Pittsburgh in advance of Thursday's Game 2 of the Eastern Conference finals, though, he was clearly excited about the chance to return to the front office. "I've had other opportunities to go back ... and this is really the first time that I've seen something that has piqued my interest," he said. The 47-year-old McGuire, who got his start in broadcasting on the radio for the Montreal Canadiens, has examples to follow in John Davidson and Dale Tallon. Davidson, the former St. Louis Blues and New York Rangers goalie who became a high-profile and well-regarded television analyst, was hired by the Blues to be team president in 2006. Tallon, Chicago's general manager, called games on television and radio between stints in the Blackhawks' front office. Barry Melrose's failure in Tampa Bay last fall is still fresh, however. Melrose was out of coaching for 13 years at ESPN before being lured back to the bench. He was fired by the Lightning 16 games into the season. The biggest risk for Leipold is that it's been so long since McGuire was paid to manage - as opposed to offering insight and opinions without a particular team's success or failure on the line. But McGuire pointed to his experience working with Scotty Bowman and Bob Johnson with Pittsburgh in the early 1990s, when he scouted opponents and spent time on the bench as an assistant while the Penguins won a pair of Stanley Cups. "Even if you're half awake, you're going to learn something, and if you're really awake you're going to learn a lot," he said, promising that he was "really awake" during those times. Copyright 2009 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. |
Go to page : 1, 2
Similar topics
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum