wprager
Administrator
Number of posts : 52870
Age : 63
Location : Kanata
Favorite Team : Ottawa
Registration date : 2008-08-05
DefenceWinsChampionships wrote: wprager wrote: Ev wrote:i don't see your point. He's not out there to pass the puck. He's out there to stand in front of the goalie and get tips.
In a perfect world (or a video game) the passer passes, the shooter shoots, and the screener screens. But in a real game situation sometimes the screener has to shoot or make a nifty between-the-legs pass. Point is, even if his "job" is to stand in front of the net and screen the goalie, his list of potential duties includes all the rest.
Neil is not the biggest guy out there, so he's not going to necessarily make the best screener.
He certainly doesn't have the hands or quick release of Stone for those cases where he's the closest Sen to the rebound.
About the only two arguments you can make in Neil's favor is that he is tough enough to stand in there, and they can live with him missing a few games due to injuries from a slash to the knee or ankle.
Why are you arguing the point? There is no arguing it. He's not the only one able and willing to go to the next and take the abuse -- and he is missing those other skills that may become extremely important if the play doesn't go exactly according to plan (i.e. passer passes, shooter shoots, screener screens).
So why not put Cowen out there? I think Chiasson or Zib should have been on the ice, not Neil. Hell, I would have even put Lazar out there.
After the recent talk about Cowen's puck handling "skills" I don't think that would be the best solution. Chiasson is a big guy with great hands. Zibanejad, too. Greening (if he's in the lineup) has great PP numbers (adjusted to PP TOI).
Look, I'm really not trying to discount Neil's contribution but when he is out there on the PP he is not contributing in a meaningful way. This isn't House PeeWee where everybody gets to play in all situations.
_________________
Hey, I don't have all the answers. In life, to be honest, I've failed as much as I have succeeded. But I love my wife. I love my life. And I wish you my kind of success.
- Dicky Fox